About The Song
When The Statler Brothers released “Susan When She Tried” on their 1981 album The Statler Brothers, it became an instant favorite among fans who appreciated the group’s ability to blend storytelling with traditional country music. Written by Don Reid, the song paints a poignant picture of love, loss, and the emotional complexity of relationships. The song speaks to the vulnerability and the effort required to keep a relationship intact, encapsulating the sense of regret and reflection that comes when love falters despite one’s best efforts.
Lyrically, “Susan When She Tried” captures the painful realization of love lost, following the story of a woman, Susan, who “tried” her best to make the relationship work, but ultimately couldn’t overcome the emotional distance between her and her partner. The line “Susan, when she tried, I know she tried” perfectly encapsulates the heartache of unreciprocated effort—how, despite the best intentions, things sometimes slip through our fingers. The song’s simplicity and emotional honesty make it one of The Statler Brothers’ most powerful ballads.
Musically, the arrangement is understated, allowing the song’s emotional weight to shine through. The Statler Brothers’ trademark harmonies are at the forefront, with each member adding depth and tenderness to the narrative. The gentle steel guitar, soft percussion, and acoustic guitar create a melancholy backdrop that complements the reflective lyrics, allowing the listener to truly feel the loss conveyed by the song.
Although “Susan When She Tried” was not released as a single, it quickly became a fan favorite, often included in concert setlists due to its emotional depth and relatable themes. The track’s resonance is especially strong with listeners who understand the quiet struggles of relationships, the times when one person puts in the effort but cannot undo the disconnect that has formed.
Even years after its release, “Susan When She Tried” remains a classic in The Statler Brothers’ repertoire. Its raw, emotional storytelling and the sincerity of the group’s performance ensure its place as a deeply touching and timeless piece of country music. The song is a reminder of the complexity of love and relationships, and the heartache that can come when someone tries their best but ultimately falls short in the eyes of the one they love.